Visiting Ample Hills Creamery at Disney’s Boardwalk

Boardwalks, summer days and ice-cream seem to go hand-in-hand.

On our visit to Disney’s Boardwalk Inn Resort, we came across  Ample Hills Creamery.   In planning our visit we thought about visiting Beaches and Cream (known for their Mickey Sink) at the Beach Club Resort located a short walk or boat ride across the way from the Boardwalk Inn. While exploring the Boardwalk we saw Ample Hills Creamery and decided to check it out instead.

Mickey Sink photo from easywdw.com

About Ample Hills Creamery

Ample Hills Creamery is actually a trendy ice-cream shop located in Brooklyn.  They have a handful of locations in New York.  Their website states they use the best ingredients including hormone-free milk and cream from grass-fed cows and organic cane sugar.  The Disney Boardwalk location opened in May 2016.

I am not a big ice-cream fan.  I like it on occasion, but typically a bite or two and I’m done. The kids enjoy ice-cream and it’s great for making memories; especially when hanging out on a boardwalk where the smell of waffle cones and funnel cakes fill the air.

Ample Hills Creamery at Disney’s Boardwalk

We visited one evening on our trip.  Even before you enter, the lit up sign on the outside looks like it’s a whimsical fun place.  It wasn’t too busy when we walked in but shortly thereafter the line got much longer.

Build Your Own Sundae

Not sure what you want? There are some handy directions while you wait in line to order.

 Order Flowchart

Want to know how it works before you get up there? No worries! They have an easy order flowchart to follow!

Ice-Cream Flavors at Ample Hills Creamery

Peppermint Pattie Ice Cream 

Cool Peppermint Ice Cream with flakes of Dark Chocolate and  House-made Peppermint Patties

Sweet Cream n’ Cookies Ice Cream 

Sweet Cream Ice Cream with pieces of Back-To-Nature Sandwich Creme Cookies

Chocolate Milk and Cookies Ice Cream 

Creamy Milk Chocolate Ice Cream with Pieces of Back-To-Nature Sandwich Creme Cookies

Ooey Gooey Butter Cake Ice Cream 

the creamiest Vanilla Ice Cream made with Cream Cheese and gobs of House-made St. Louis-Style Ooey Gooey Butter Cake. A staff favorite!

PB Wins the Cup Ice Cream 

Vanilla Ice Cream with Peanut Butter Chocolate flakes and House-made Peanut Butter Cups

Cotton Candy Ice Cream 

100% All-Natural Blue Cotton Candy Ice Cream made with no Artificial Colors of Flavors

Coffee Toffee Coffee Ice Cream 

Coffee Ice Cream with Housemade Espresso-Infused Chocolate-Covered Toffee Pieces

Butter Pecan Brittle Ice Cream 

Dark Brown Sugar Ice Cream with Pieces of Housemade Roasted Pecan Brittle

Nonna D’s Oatmeal Lace Ice Cream 

Dark Brown Sugar Cinnamon Ice Cream with Housemade Oatmeal Lace Cookies

Vanilla Bean Ice Cream 

Vanilla Bean Ice Cream made with Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Beans

Baked/Unbaked Ice Cream 

Vanilla Ice Cream with pieces of Housemade Chocolate Chip Cookies and Brown Butter Cookie Dough

Dark Chocolate Ice Cream 

Rich Dark Chocolate Ice Cream made with 72% E. Guiffard Chocolate

Lemon Sky Ice Cream 

Light and Billowy Lemon Ginger Sorbet made with a splash of Limoncello. Dairy-free and Vegan

Strawberries and Cream Ice Cream 

Smooth and Pure Strawberry Ice Cream

Sally Sells Seashells Ice Cream 

Fresh and Fluffy Orange Marshmallow Ice Cream with House-made Salty Chocolate Seashells

You can get these in an Ice Cream Cup, Cake Cone, Waffle Cone, Pretzel Cone, M&M Cone, Chocolate Cookie Cone, Cookie, or Milkshake.

Decisions, Decisions! Our Ice-Cream Order

My son wanted an ice-cream sandwich cookie, my daughter asked for the brownie sundae (which was gigantic so they were able to do a smaller version with one scoop of ice cream, a brownie, and some hot fudge. ) and I had the sweet cream and cookies in a waffle cone.  My husband knew there’d be plenty to go around so he shared with all of us.

Ice-cream Cookie Sandwich with Sprinkles

Single Scoop Vanilla Ice-Cream with Brownie and Hot Fudge

Single Scoop Sweet Cream and Cookies In a waffle cone

For the Ice-Cream Cookie Sandwich, they even heated the cookies first so they were nice and soft.  They also heated the brownie for the sundae also.   This may seem like a small detail but it really isn’t when it comes down to the taste of it.

The Sweet Cream and Cookies waffle cone was the most amazing ice-cream I’ve ever had.  In fact, it’s a really good thing I don’t live close to one of these.  This ice-cream could make me an ice-cream person.  It was full of cookies and creamy- just amazing!

The Verdict on Ample Hills Creamery

Amazing.  Absolutely amazing.  Skip Beaches and Cream and go straight for this if you’re wanting ice-cream.  Hang out on the Boardwalk and enjoy the entertainment and lights while you enjoy your sweet treat.  It truly brings all the magic together.

*They do accept the Disney Dining Plan snack credit for payment also.